As early as tomorrow, the Senate will be discussing the immigration bill or the “Grand Compromise” that was turned down few weeks ago. For those who just started to follow this news, I would like to explain reasons why you don’t want this bill to go through.
Before I get into the details, I want you to know that as an immigrant myself, I do support immigrant rights. I believe that everyone including legal (including the dependents who are the spouse or children of a visa holder) and illegal immigrants should be able to work in the United States. However, this so-called “Grand Compromise” Bill gives false hope to everyone including immigrants and the United States citizens. Therefore, I don’t support the bill.
Why should you not support the bill?
First, the bill is more than 300 pages long. According to the White House, no other provisions in the bill will be implemented unless the border is secure.
Under The Bipartisan Immigration Reform Bill, Temporary Worker And Z Visas Will Not Be Issued Until Border Security Benchmarks Are Met. These triggers include:
- Increasing border fencing.
- Increasing vehicle barriers at the Southern border.
- Increasing the size of the Border Patrol.
- Installing ground-based radar and camera towers along the Southern border.
- Ensuring resources are available to maintain the effective end of “Catch and Release” for every non-Mexican apprehended at the borders.
Source: Whitehouse.gov
This provision of the bill alone has made me go crazy. If the Congress is going to legalize illegal immigrants, then it has to be in a separate bill, not including border security. If the Congress is going to pass a bill that would beef up the border security, then it should not mention legalization of illegal immigration at all. Also, how would you, as in those who support this bill and the Congress define secured-border? When is the border going to be secure? How is it going to take?
Clearly, this bill gives false hopes to illegal immigrants. They’re not going to get legal status because no one knows when the border is going to be “secured” and ‘illegal immigrant” free.
Secondly, what about those legal immigrants who are in the U.S legally? Some legal immigrants are the follower of their spouse or parents can not obtain work because their visa doesn’t allow them to work. How about those people? If the Congress is going to allow illegal immigrants to work, it must allow dependent immigrants to work as well.
Thirdly, the USCIS is not ready to deal with 12 million or so petitions for Z visa, period. If it can’t issue U.S citizens passport on time, then what make you think it’s going to be able to handle the Z visa petitions?
Lastly, the Congress needs more time to discuss this issue. The reason that Bush wants this pass is because he wants to save his butt from “The U.S President Hall of Shame.” If the Congress truely cares about the immigration issue, it neeeds more time to talk about it, period.